How to spot a fake vintage football shirt
Three kinds of old-looking football shirt are for sale. Only one of them is a problem. This is how to tell them apart before you pay.
Original, remake or fake
An original was made for the season it is from and sold at the time. That is what vintage means in our shop.
An official remake is a new shirt in an old design, made under licence. There is nothing wrong with a remake. It is a different thing, and it should be sold as one.
A fake is an unlicensed copy. There are a lot of them. UK police seized more than 220,000 fake football items, worth over £18m, during the 2026 World Cup, as BBC Sport reported. Here in Edinburgh, the council's Trading Standards team seized an estimated 58,000 counterfeit jerseys and kits, according to the council.
One word causes confusion: replica. An official replica is a licensed supporter shirt, not a counterfeit. Some genuine shirts say so on the label. One of our own listings, a 2000/01 Wimbledon home shirt by Puma, has a neck label reading "Official Replica Product".
Start with the year
What you can check depends on when the shirt was made.
From around the early 2000s, most of the large makers began adding a product code to the labels inside their shirts. A code can be searched.
Before that, there is usually no code. That is normal, and it is not a sign of a fake. With an older shirt you compare what is in front of you with a known original.
Shirts from the 2000s onwards: find the code
Where the code sits depends on the maker. Makers changed their labels over the years, so treat these as a guide.
- Nike: a small white label inside the shirt near the bottom hem. The usual form is a six-character style number, a dash and a three-digit colour code.
- adidas: a label at the neck on recent shirts. On shirts from before about 2010, a label on the side seam beside the wash labels.
- Puma: a label in the side seam near the waist, marked "Style No" or "Article No".
- Umbro: no single format. A number on an Umbro wash label is not a product code, and searching it tells you nothing.
Search the code with the maker's name. The results should show the same club, season and colour. If they show a different shirt, stop and ask the seller about it. A matching code is a good sign, not proof, because codes can be copied. The rest of the shirt has to agree with it.
Shirts from before 2000: compare it with a known original
With no code, the work is slower. There is no shortcut. Each shirt has to be compared with photographs of an example you trust. Five things to compare:
- The collar label. Is it the label that maker used in that period?
- The crest. Is it embroidered, woven or printed, and does that match?
- The maker's logo. Is it in the same place and at the same size?
- The sponsor. Is the lettering the same, and applied the same way?
- The stitching. Is it even, and finished the same way?


It also helps to know who made a club's shirts in a given season. Hibernian's shirts were made by Mitre from 1994 to 1998 and by Le Coq Sportif from 1998 to 2010. A Hibs shirt offered as early 2000s with another maker's logo on it needs an explanation.
Signs in the listing
Often the listing tells you enough, before you see a label.
- The same old shirt in every size. An original from before 2000 is rarely on offer in every size. Unworn old stock does occasionally surface in more than one size, but think twice.
- The photographs. A stock image tells you nothing about the shirt you will receive. Ask to see the labels. A seller who refuses is a warning.
- The words. "Retro" and "replica" are used loosely. If a listing does not say whether a shirt is an original or a remake, ask.
What a label cannot tell you
A correct label shows that a shirt is a genuine product of its maker. It does not show that a player wore it. Neither "player version" nor a name and number on the back establishes that. A match-worn claim needs evidence of its own. A signature is a separate question again. Ask who issued the certificate.
How we handle it at Forever Vintage
Our vintage shirts are original club and country shirts from past seasons. Some things in the shop are new, and we say so: the scarves, keyrings and other accessories, and the Bear T-shirts. And where one of the framed signed pieces is signed on a later remake, the listing says it.
If we are not sure about a shirt, it is removed from sale.
Every photograph on a listing is of that shirt, not a stock image. A shirt photographed to our current standard shows the front, the back, the crest or sponsor, the neck label with the maker and size, and the worst flaw we can find. Older listings carry fewer photographs. If the label is not shown and you want to know what it says, email hello@forever-vintage.co.uk before you buy. One of us will look at the shirt and tell you. Our guide to reading a listing explains the rest of the page.
Some of our signed shirts come with a certificate and a photograph. Some come with the shirt alone. Ask before you buy and we will tell you which.
In our two Edinburgh shops you can turn a shirt inside out yourself.
If we get it wrong, the answer is simple. If a shirt is not what we said it is, you get every penny back, whenever you find out. On a signed shirt that covers the signature as well. The promise is set out in our terms of sale.
A short checklist
- Is it sold as an original or a remake? If the listing does not say, ask.
- Made in the 2000s or later? Find the product code and search it.
- Made before 2000? Compare the labels, crest, maker's logo, sponsor and stitching with a known original.
- Is it one shirt in one size, or every size?
- Are the photographs of this shirt, with its labels?
- What happens if it turns out to be wrong?
Shirts from before product codes are in the 1990s collection. Shirts from the first years of codes are in the 2000s collection.